Donate Now to Support KDHX

Listen Live
Sunday, 22 July 2012 15:57

Melodramatic 'Trishna' unfolds slowly; 'Bill W.' seeks to inspire

thefinaltake.com thefinaltake.com
Written by Diane Carson
Rate this item
(0 votes)

About this Media...

  • Director: Michael Winterbottom, Dan Carracino and Kevin Hanlon
  • Dates: July 26, 2012 and opens July 27, 2012

Reinterpreting classic novels proves irresistible to filmmakers, and British director Michael Winterbottom has taken the bait with Trishna. This version of English novelist Thomas Hardy’s melodramatic Tess of the d’Urbervilles moves Hardy’s 1891 story to contemporary India where class and gender inequities rule and defeat the beautiful Trishna and the callous Jay.

As a result of an accident telegraphed well before it happens, Trishna must accept a hotel job with sufficient pay to sustain her family. Her wealthy boss and soon her lover, Jay embodies Buddhism’s second noble truth: trishna, that is desire or thirst which leads to suffering and perhaps enlightenment. The particulars develop in a slowly paced moral tale.

As the character Trishna, the lovely Freida Pinto, of Slumdog Millionaire fame, poses nicely but communicates little depth or conflict. The same is true for Roshan Seth as Jay, a carelessly self-indulgent, controlling young man. Still his hedonism and Trishna’s victimization come across as much too listless, failing to energize a climactic scene.

While beautifully photographed, the episodic story is repeatedly punctuated with shots of the beach, Mumbai, the resort, and various surroundings. But rather than adding depth, these interruptions distract from the focus. Winterbottom knows his way around a set, having directed the amusing The Trip with Steve Coogan, the intense Welcome to Sarajevo, A Mighty Heart based on the Daniel Pearl tragedy and two other films based on Hardy novels. Trishna, however, lacks the energy and complexity needed to bring this hardy adaptation to vivid life, to make the unjust social structure and the insensitivity on display infuriating and profound. It provides only a leisurely indulgence. In English and Hindi with English subtitles. At a Landmark Theatre.

On Thursday, July 26th only the documentary Bill W. will screen at the Tivoli at 7:00 p.m. Though I did not get to preview it, the film tells the life story of Bill Wilson, co-founder of Alcoholics Anonymous in the mid-30s and listed as one of the 100 most important persons of the 20th century by Time magazine. Directed by Dan Carracino and Kevin Hanlon, Bill W. includes archival footage writing an essay of Wilson himself and Dr. Bob plus recreations of events, interviews and testimonials of recovering alcoholics, and description of the A.A. Twelve Step program. Bill W. notes Wilson’s amazing legacy forged from his own hopeless alcoholism. At the Tivoli.
 

Sponsor Message

Become a Sponsor

Find KDHX Online

KDHX on Instagram
KDHX on YouTube
KDHX on SoundCloud
KDHX on Facebook
KDHX on Twitter
KDHX on flickr

KDHX Recommends

May
Thursday
07

Midwest Mayhem presented by KDHX

KDHX proudly presents the 10th Midwest Mayhem, KDHX’s biggest party of the year, sprawling across 600,000 square feet of the famed City Museum. Tons of bands and DJs are scheduled to perform, as well as other wild...


May
Friday
08

New Music Circle presents Tim Berne's Snakeoil

New York-based alto saxophonist Tim Berne has long been regarded as one of the Downtown scene’s most forward thinking bandleaders. Active in New York since 1974, Berne has fostered the creative talent of subsequent...


May
Saturday
09

Brunch at the Stage: JD Hughes

KDHX is now curating a Saturday brunch series at the Stage with live music from local musicians and delicious, locally-sourced food and drinks from the Magnolia Café. Brunch at the Stage takes place from 9 a.m. to 1 p.m....


Get Answers!

If you have questions or need to contact KDHX, visit our answers portal at answers.kdhx.org.

Online Users

2 users and 13828 guests online
Sign in with Facebook

SYSTEM: S5 Box

Login/My Account

Sign in with Facebook