Local opening date: December 25, 2007
Reviewed by Diane Carson
election year, there isn't a more relevant film than The Great Debaters. But it isn't about presidential candidates,
though they could learn a valuable lesson here. It's about the incomparable
debate team from small Wiley College, Marshall,
Texas, in the mid 1930s.
a true story, poetic license is taken; for example, the important debate at
Harvard was against the University
of Southern California.
But the heart of the film is pure and deeply moving precisely because, on the
whole, it eschews histrionics in favor of intelligent analysis and commentary.
The mid-30s in northeast Texas,
as elsewhere, were deeply racist and sexist; director Denzel Washington never
glosses over the negative elements. But his debaters get on with their work-to
strengthen their minds, to hone their intellect. For in this story of
excellence and hard work, a great deal more than winning a debate is at stake.
Washington plays Melvin Tolson, the son of a Missouri preacher. A formidable mentor,
Tolson secretly helps organize poor sharecroppers, white and black, while
teaching at all-black Wiley and coaching the debate team. For the first-time
since he began teaching at Wiley in 1923, Tolson selects a female, Samantha, as
one of the two debate team alternates, breaking another barrier-the gender one.
A romance develops; jealousy simmers; the preacher father of the second
alternate, 14 year old James Farmer, Jr. has misgivings; and, more importantly,
a lynching occurs and an arrest for union action. Clear-eyed presentation of
important history lifts what could easily have been a David and Goliath tale
above any melodramatic pandering. But what The
Great Debaters doesn't admit is that the Pi Kappa Delta debate society
never officially acknowledged the most crucial victory since it didn't
recognize black debaters before WWII. Nevertheless, this film gives them their
due and the actors shine: Denzel Washington, Forest Whitaker, and all the
others. It's particularly refreshing to see intellectual achievement celebrated
and made exciting.
Denzel Washington does a fine job in the
director's chair, never flamboyant as his smart technical choices serve the
story. The Great Debaters has won the
National Board of Reviews Freedom of Expression award.
KDHX is having a rent party and we want you to join us.
Thursday, September 10th at the Old Rock House Jake’s Leg and 710 will be hosting a fun evening of music and comradery in support of KDHX. 710 will kick off the evening...