Donate Now to Support KDHX

Listen Live
Thursday, 16 September 2010 12:52

See it at the Rep, but You Can't Take It With You

Written by Andrea Braun

The Details

See it at the Rep, but You Can't Take It With You
Courtesy of Repertory Theatre of St. Louis, © Photo by Jerry Naunheim Jr.

It's always a pleasure to spend time with the Vanderhof/Sycamore clan, and the Rep's production of the George F. Kaufman and Moss Hart classic You Can't Take It With You finds them as quirky and appealing as ever. The performances are uniformly excellent, Steven Woolf's direction keeps the actors and the action moving at a brisk comic pace, and the message that the best things in life are free comes through loud and clear.

The playbill has a lot of interesting information on the era of the play, which was written during the Great Depression of the 1930s. Contemporary audiences can connect with Grandpa Vanderhof's (Joneal Joplin) views on taxes (he doesn't pay them because he doesn't know what he's getting) and the business world (he just walked away 35 years earlier to do what he pleased). He mentions immigration, another hot button issue of our own time, and one illustrated in the play by Russian royalists, Boris Kolenkhov (hilariously depicted by Anderson Matthews) and the Grand Duchess Olga Katrina (Barbara Kingsley). Kolenkhov is younger daughter, Essie Carmichael's (Stephanie Cozart) ballet instructor. The fact that Kolenkhov is crazy (funny crazy, not scary crazy) and Essie has no talent don't matter at all. 

Essie dances around the house eternally making candies served from a human skull. Her husband, Ed (Jamie LaVerdiere) peddles Essie's treats around the neighborhood. He is a good natured simpleton with a printing press that eventually gets him in hot water, a penchant for the xylophone and mask-making. Essie's sister, Alice (Amelia McClain), is the “Marilyn Munster” of the bunch: She doesn't seem eccentric, she has a normal job and is being courted by the boss's son, Tony Kirby (Benjamin Eakeley). Carol Schultz as Penny Sycamore is a supremely ditzy mother to the girls, wife to Paul (Tony Campisi) and daughter of Grandpa Vanderhof. Even Penny calls him “Grandpa,” not “Father.” This seems to emphasize his role as generic patriarch, the elder of the family who receives love and respect in his own home, an enviable position.

Paul Sycamore's hobby is fireworks, and he is assisted by Mr. De Pinna (Scott Schafer). They work in the basement, and the little firecracker we see is like Chekhov's gun, which does what it's supposed to at the end of Act II. The Sycamore's collect objects AND people. Susie Wall has a funny turn as a drunk, down-at-heels actress Penny meets on a bus and brings home to “audition” for a part in one of her plays. Writing plays has been her avocation for the last eight years, ever since a typewriter was delivered to the home by mistake. Previously (and briefly again during the play) she painted, and her final unfinished work of Mr. De Pinna as the discus thrower is revived with the toga-clad De Pinna continuing as her model. Grandpa raises snakes in the dining room, collects stamps, attends commencements, and visits with the neighborhood policeman who he talked into following his own dream after graduating from medical school.

Rheba (Rachel Leslie), the maid and less than gifted cook, and her boyfriend, Donald (Scott Whitehurst), round out the group. Donald is on “relief,” the only direct reference to the Depression, but he is nattily dressed and resents the time (about a half hour a week) he has to stand in line to get his check. They veer toward stereotype, though Rheba is well-spoken, and they are valued members of the family.

Grandpa's tax evasion catches up with him, providing some dramatic tension, but the Deus ex Machina had to be appealing to contemporaneous audiences. Further, Alice doesn't accept Tony's marriage proposal at first because she is afraid their families won't get along, and she is very attached to hers. He convinces her to agree to marry him though, and they arrange to get them all together for a dinner. The whole family is excitedly preparing for the visit from Tony and his parents (Jeffrey Hayenga and Kingsley) but are surprised by the company arriving a day early as they are going about the monkey business that comprises a normal day. Mayhem ensues.

Acts I and II are charming. The Sycamores, then the Sycamores with the Kirbys provide some excellent comic bits. The wit and wisdom of Grandpa combined with the hijinks perpetrated by the others make for a lot of fun. But Act III, even at just under a half hour, seems pat and it drags. Kingsley as the Duchess-turned-waitress does her best to insert some life into the proceedings, but for me, at least, it just didn't happen. Most damaging to the play is that, at this point in the unpredictable Vanderhof house, the action becomes predictable.

The set is a marvel. As Woolf writes in the Director's Notes, you feel like you could move in. A reproduction of the late-Victorian painting “Flaming June,” a recumbent young woman in a bright orange dress hangs over the fireplace, a fitting household goddess, and there are too many other interesting objects to begin to mention. The 18 actors (a small cast for a Kaufman and Hart  play, we're told) have plenty of room to move around. Credit John Ezell. Elizabeth Covey's costumes, Peter Sargent's lights and Rusty Wandall's sound all enhance the look and feel of the production.

I enjoyed seeing this show, and particularly with this cast, especially Joplin, Schultz, and Matthews. And, As Grandpa observes, “Life's kinda beautiful if you just let it come to you.” It's a pleasant way to kick off another season at The Rep.

Additional Info

KDHX Recommends


Folk Song Sing-A-Long

Folk Song Sing-A-Long Presented in partnership with the Folk School of KDHX, weekly meetings will discuss and sing different periods of folk music.  Presented by St. Louis OASIS.


Welcome To Our Movie: The Bottle Rockets Live & In Person

In 2009, a live show by iconic Midwestern rock band The Bottle Rockets was filmed with the intention of releasing it as a live concert DVD. As the footage moved through post-production, it transformed into a more ambitious project...


Folk and Roots Sessions: The Yellow-Bellied Sapsuckers

The Folk & Roots Sessions, a 10-concert series spanning August, 2015 to May, 2016, will bring you new folk, bluegrass, old-time, Americana or country. Each month the Folk & Roots Sessions will feature one concert we think you...


Login/My Account

Sign in with Facebook